Bibliographic information
Recommendation
Pyrethroid-pyriproxyfen ITNs are not recommended for deployment over pyrethroid-PBO ITNs for prevention of malaria in adults and children in areas with pyrethroid resistance.
Recommended against
Conditional
Certainty of evidence
Moderate
Notes and Remarks
Remarks The conditionality of the recommendation against the deployment of pyrethroid-pyriproxyfen ITNs instead of pyrethroid-PBOITNs is based on the GDG’s judgement that the balance of effects favours pyrethroid-PBO ITNs over pyrethroid-pyriproxyfenITNs and that, based on current cost and efficacy data, pyrethroid-PBO ITNs are more cost-effective. The GDG acknowledgedthat evidence to support this recommendation is derived from only a single trial in Africa.
Practical info Given that pyrethroid‐pyriproxyfen ITNs are designed to provide improved impact against resistant mosquitoes, pyrethroid resistance in potential target areas should be confirmed using standard procedures [22], as should susceptibility of the local vectors to pyriproxyfen. In any case, pyrethroid‐pyriproxyfen ITNs should not be considered a tool that alone can effectively manage insecticide resistance in malaria vectors. As with all malaria interventions, post-distribution monitoring of ITNs to estimate coverage in terms of access to and use of ITNs is recommended. WHO also recommends that programmes conduct studies of ITN survival each time a campaign uses a new product such as pyrethroid‐pyriproxyfen ITNs, including assessment of ITN integrity. Such studies will provide information on the life span of the product under field conditions and thus enable estimation of the period over which the additional impact against malaria may be maintained. The systematic review reported that, two years after deployment, 39% of pyrethroid‐pyriproxyfen ITNs were torn (defined as having a total hole area ≥ 790 cm² and therefore assumed to be not fit for use), compared to 28% of pyrethroid-only LLINs and 43% of pyrethroid-PBO ITNs.
Also Featured In
This recommendation also appears in the following guidelines:
WHO guidelines for malaria, 16 October 2023.
WHO Guidelines for malaria, 14 March 2023